
BUD 501
Mind and Its World I: Valid Cognition
Faculty: Arne Schelling
This course explores the question: How do you obtain accurate and valid knowledge about the world? That's the subject of pramana, or Buddhist epistemology. We typically assume that what we know about the world is valid. But is it? Our mind processes information so quickly, it responds so fast to what's happening around us that we usually don't realize when we are having a conceptual experience that is not actually in agreement with the object that we are experiencing.
Course Description: This course is an introductory exposition of topics drawn from the Pramāna tradition, based on the Classifications of Mind root text. Students explore the criteria for the validity of cognition, the fourfold classification of direct valid cognition, seeming direct cognition and non-valid cognition.
PREREQUISITE:
- None
REQUIRED TEXTS:
- Root text: Classifications of Mind (Lorik), by Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoche, Nitartha Institute Publications
- Mind & Its World 1 Sourcebook, Nitartha Institute Publications
DATES & TIMES:
Sundays September 7 - December 17, 2025, 11:30 am - 1:00 pm US Pacific Time 8:30pm - 10pm CET
COST:
$200
Nitartha’s Payment Plan and Financial Assistance (PPFA) program is funded by fellow students to support those who would not be able to attend the Institute’s courses without this assistance. To request aid, please fill out the PPFA application before you register for the course.
WHAT YOU WILL BE INTRODUCED TO:
(This is a small sampling of the topics covered in this course.)
In this course, we become able to distinguish between what our mind tells us versus the way things are. And when we do that, we begin to understand the meaning of valid cognition and non-valid cognition. We start to see that there is a difference between our conceptual understanding of a thing and our direct experience of it. In fact, when we study Pramana, we discover that most or nearly all of our experiences are conceptual, and that conceptuality is a rather fuzzy representation of the way things are.
What is it that is having these experiences? We can call it mind, consciousness or awareness. Here in the pramana system of classification they are all equivalents, but we can differentiate between a conceptual mind, a non-conceptual mind, a valid mind or a non-valid mind.
What makes a mind or cognition valid? What makes it non-valid? To answer these questions, we delve into the definitions of mind, consciousness, and awareness, of valid and non-valid cognition. We explore how valid cognition can be ascertained directly through our senses, or inferentially through valid concepts. That's right, in Pramana, not all concepts are non-valid!
For Pramana, the task of the dharma practitioner is first to differentiate between valid and non-valid cognition, and then to clarify that valid cognition can be inferential or direct valid cognition. That's the path. Direct valid cognition is even more valid than inferential. For example, consider the difference between thinking about chocolate and eating it. Inference is good, but it's even more delicious through direct valid cognition.
How a sense consciousness arises is just one of the ways in which this course explores how mind works. In addition, it describes the objects that our mind is experiencing, which are also essential to know in order to understand mind itself. So we have things and non-things, objects, existents and non-existents, conditioned phenomena and non-conditioned phenomena. We discover how to classify everything under the sun, and then some.
But classifying what our mind experiences is not just an intellectual or theoretical exercise. It actually helps us to understand our mind as well as its world. And once we understand how much of its world is actually just our own mental experiences, or projections, then we can start to question our own reactions, and perhaps begin to change them.
LEARN WITH OUR RENOWNED FACULTY

Arne Schelling
Arne Schelling has followed Dzogchen Ponlop Rinpoche since 1989 and has been a dharma teacher and translator for various sanghas in all Tibetan Buddhist traditions for nearly two decades. Originally trained and having worked as a physician for 20 years, Arne has devotedly participated in the Nitartha Institute since 1999 and has helped to establish various Buddhist centers in Germany. He is an archivist, videographer, piano player, and is currently in a 10-year teacher training program at Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche’s Milinda Project. Arne works full time at the Khyentse Vision Project, 84000, Longchen Shedra and other publishing projects. He is also a student of the Nalanda Master Course.